Priors and payoffs in confidence judgments - Archive ouverte HAL Access content directly
Journal Articles Attention, Perception, and Psychophysics Year : 2020

Priors and payoffs in confidence judgments

Elon Gaffin-Cahn
  • Function : Author
Nadia Hosseinizaveh
  • Function : Author
Pascal Mamassian
Michael S Landy
  • Function : Author


Priors and payoffs are known to affect perceptual decision-making, but little is understood about how they influence confidence judgments. For optimal perceptual decision-making, both priors and payoffs should be considered when selecting a response. However, for confidence to reflect the probability of being correct in a perceptual decision, priors should affect confidence but payoffs should not. To experimentally test whether human observers follow this normative behavior for natural confidence judgments, we conducted an orientation-discrimination task with varied priors and payoffs that probed both perceptual and metacognitive decision-making. The placement of discrimination and confidence criteria were examined according to several plausible Signal Detection Theory models. In the normative model, observers use the optimal discrimination criterion (i.e., the criterion that maximizes expected gain) and confidence criteria that shift with the discrimination criterion that maximizes accuracy (i.e., are not affected by payoffs). No observer was consistent with this model, with the majority exhibiting non-normative confidence behavior. One subset of observers ignored both priors and payoffs for confidence, always fixing the confidence criteria around the neutral discrimination criterion. The other group of observers incorrectly incorporated payoffs into their confidence by always shifting their confidence criteria with the same gains-maximizing criterion used for discrimination. Such metacognitive mistakes could have negative consequences outside the laboratory setting, particularly when priors or payoffs are not matched for all the possible decision alternatives.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
Locke2020_priorsPayoffsConfidence.pdf (2.66 Mo) Télécharger le fichier
Origin : Files produced by the author(s)

Dates and versions

hal-02876782 , version 1 (10-07-2020)



Shannon M Locke, Elon Gaffin-Cahn, Nadia Hosseinizaveh, Pascal Mamassian, Michael S Landy. Priors and payoffs in confidence judgments. Attention, Perception, and Psychophysics, 2020, ⟨10.3758/s13414-020-02018-x⟩. ⟨hal-02876782⟩
25 View
99 Download



Gmail Facebook Twitter LinkedIn More